NYC Data Science Academy| Blog
Bootcamps
Lifetime Job Support Available Financing Available
Bootcamps
Data Science with Machine Learning Flagship ๐Ÿ† Data Analytics Bootcamp Artificial Intelligence Bootcamp New Release ๐ŸŽ‰
Free Lesson
Intro to Data Science New Release ๐ŸŽ‰
Find Inspiration
Find Alumni with Similar Background
Job Outlook
Occupational Outlook Graduate Outcomes Must See ๐Ÿ”ฅ
Alumni
Success Stories Testimonials Alumni Directory Alumni Exclusive Study Program
Courses
View Bundled Courses
Financing Available
Bootcamp Prep Popular ๐Ÿ”ฅ Data Science Mastery Data Science Launchpad with Python View AI Courses Generative AI for Everyone New ๐ŸŽ‰ Generative AI for Finance New ๐ŸŽ‰ Generative AI for Marketing New ๐ŸŽ‰
Bundle Up
Learn More and Save More
Combination of data science courses.
View Data Science Courses
Beginner
Introductory Python
Intermediate
Data Science Python: Data Analysis and Visualization Popular ๐Ÿ”ฅ Data Science R: Data Analysis and Visualization
Advanced
Data Science Python: Machine Learning Popular ๐Ÿ”ฅ Data Science R: Machine Learning Designing and Implementing Production MLOps New ๐ŸŽ‰ Natural Language Processing for Production (NLP) New ๐ŸŽ‰
Find Inspiration
Get Course Recommendation Must Try ๐Ÿ’Ž An Ultimate Guide to Become a Data Scientist
For Companies
For Companies
Corporate Offerings Hiring Partners Candidate Portfolio Hire Our Graduates
Students Work
Students Work
All Posts Capstone Data Visualization Machine Learning Python Projects R Projects
Tutorials
About
About
About Us Accreditation Contact Us Join Us FAQ Webinars Subscription An Ultimate Guide to
Become a Data Scientist
    Login
NYC Data Science Acedemy
Bootcamps
Courses
Students Work
About
Bootcamps
Bootcamps
Data Science with Machine Learning Flagship
Data Analytics Bootcamp
Artificial Intelligence Bootcamp New Release ๐ŸŽ‰
Free Lessons
Intro to Data Science New Release ๐ŸŽ‰
Find Inspiration
Find Alumni with Similar Background
Job Outlook
Occupational Outlook
Graduate Outcomes Must See ๐Ÿ”ฅ
Alumni
Success Stories
Testimonials
Alumni Directory
Alumni Exclusive Study Program
Courses
Bundles
financing available
View All Bundles
Bootcamp Prep
Data Science Mastery
Data Science Launchpad with Python NEW!
View AI Courses
Generative AI for Everyone
Generative AI for Finance
Generative AI for Marketing
View Data Science Courses
View All Professional Development Courses
Beginner
Introductory Python
Intermediate
Python: Data Analysis and Visualization
R: Data Analysis and Visualization
Advanced
Python: Machine Learning
R: Machine Learning
Designing and Implementing Production MLOps
Natural Language Processing for Production (NLP)
For Companies
Corporate Offerings
Hiring Partners
Candidate Portfolio
Hire Our Graduates
Students Work
All Posts
Capstone
Data Visualization
Machine Learning
Python Projects
R Projects
About
Accreditation
About Us
Contact Us
Join Us
FAQ
Webinars
Subscription
An Ultimate Guide to Become a Data Scientist
Tutorials
Data Analytics
  • Learn Pandas
  • Learn NumPy
  • Learn SciPy
  • Learn Matplotlib
Machine Learning
  • Boosting
  • Random Forest
  • Linear Regression
  • Decision Tree
  • PCA
Interview by Companies
  • JPMC
  • Google
  • Facebook
Artificial Intelligence
  • Learn Generative AI
  • Learn ChatGPT-3.5
  • Learn ChatGPT-4
  • Learn Google Bard
Coding
  • Learn Python
  • Learn SQL
  • Learn MySQL
  • Learn NoSQL
  • Learn PySpark
  • Learn PyTorch
Interview Questions
  • Python Hard
  • R Easy
  • R Hard
  • SQL Easy
  • SQL Hard
  • Python Easy
Data Science Blog > Student Works > Prescription Drug Pricing, A Case Study in Market Failure

Prescription Drug Pricing, A Case Study in Market Failure

Charlie Zien
Posted on Jul 29, 2019

Project GitHub | LinkedIn:   Niki   Moritz   Hao-Wei   Matthew   Oren

The skills we demoed here can be learned through taking Data Science with Machine Learning bootcamp with NYC Data Science Academy.

Living in the only developed nation without universal health coverage, Americans are at the mercy of pharmaceutical companies, insurers, and pharmacy benefit managers when it comes to the cost of prescription drug. As a result, we pay substantially more for our medication than people in other countries:

Drug prices by country

The out-of-pocket cost of a prescription drug largely depends on the patientโ€™s insurance. Data on insurance formularies is spread across numerous disparate sources. Even for patients paying out of pocket, US pharmacies do not publish their prices online. The resulting confusion, plus the inelastic demand for medicine, creates a highly dysfunctional market environment, with consumers footing the bill. This is a textbook example of market failure, wherein the marketโ€™s natural price-setting mechanisms become wildly distorted and inefficient, leading to a net social welfare loss.

Current Drug Pricing Mechanisms

The current pricing model involves three major players: pharmaceutical companies, insurers, and pharmacy benefit managers. With so many intermediaries taking a piece of the pie, prices have become inflated. The actual workings of this system are too complex to summarize here, but if you want to know more, Hasan Minhaj gives an informative (and hilarious) take on the situation.

Take the example of Lipitor: Buying directly from the manufacturer, a monthโ€™s supply costs around $3. Because pharmaceutical companies know insurance companies (by way of pharmacy benefit managers) negotiate heavy discounts, they price their product exorbitantly in anticipation of these negotiations. In the case of a common generic like Lipitor, most patients will end up paying a small co-pay. But patients without insurance are left to foot the bill. In this regard, a $3 bottle of Lipitor can cost an uninsured or underinsured patient as much as $130:

Prescription drug pricing scheme

In recent years, prescription savings clubs such as GoodRx, WellRx, and Familywize have emerged to help combat this problem. They negotiate directly with pharmacies and provide search aggregation tools for consumers to compare prices across pharmacies in their area. However, in spite of these tools, the market is still comically inefficient. A quick search on WellRx shows that $3 bottle of Lipitor selling for between $9 and $57 in New York, as of this writing. Looking in Dallas, it could cost as little as $5.50.

That got me thinking โ€” if prices vary so much within a city and between cities, are there any other patterns that could help consumers make more educated decisions about where they buy their prescriptions?

The Data

Given the utter lack of transparency in this industry, it is extremely difficult to find large, authoritative datasets on retail drug pricing. However, aggregators provide a useful, albeit imperfect, view on the state of the market. To get a better view on this, I built a scraping tool to perform automated searches on WellRx and log prices of the 30 most prescribed drugs across the 30 largest US cities, yielding approximately 12,000 data points after outliers were removed.

A histogram grid gives a sense of the price variation among different drugs. I added in red dashed lines to indicate the price paid by Medicaid based on data from NADAC. It doesnโ€™t take a data scientist to note that the red lines tend toward the left of their respective charts, sometimes dramatically so.

Itโ€™s a poignant indication of how the government uses its bargaining power to bring down prices. In all developed countries, with the exception of the US, citizens expect their governments to apply this leverage to keep prices low for everyone. Here, only a select few โ€” limited to low-income people and those over 65 โ€” benefit from that leverage. The rest of us, meanwhile, are left to fend for ourselves. The data reveals this hasn't been working out in our favor.

Location, Location, Location

To better visualize geographic price variation, I constructed a heatmap of z-scores for each city-drug pair relative to the average price of each drug across all cities, with higher (red) z-scores indicating higher-than-average prices:

Most Expensive Least Expensive
1. San Francisco, CA 1. Los Angeles, CA
2. Chicago, IL 2. Riverside, CA
3. St. Louis, MO 3. Minneapolis, MN
4. Portland, OR 4. Houston, TX
5. Austin, TX 5. Detroit, MI

Interestingly, the price variations do not appear to correlate with differences in cost of living, given Los Angelesโ€™s top spot on the list. Nor does it necessarily reflect effectiveness of policy, considering the most expensive city, San Francisco, is in the same state.

Turning my attention to pharmacies, I calculated average z-scores for the 20 large pharmacy franchises, with lower z-scores indicating lower prices:

Pharmacy Z-Score Pharmacy Z-Score
1. PUBLIX PHARMACY -1.17 11. GIANT PHARMACY -0.32
2. KROGER PHARMACY -1.04 12. BENZER PHARMACY -0.21
3. FRED MEYER PHARMACY -0.99 13. COSTCO PHARMACY 0.23
4. WINN DIXIE -0.94 14. RITE AID PHARMACY 0.25
5. HEB PHARMACY -0.84 15. VONS PHARMACY 0.43
6. HARRIS TEETER PHARMACY -0.76 16. RANDALLS PHARMACY 0.51
7. MEIJER PHARMACY -0.75 17. SAFEWAY PHARMACY 0.51
8. WALMART PHARMACY -0.73 18. WALGREENS 0.59
9. RALPHS PHARMACY -0.63 19. SAVON PHARMACY 0.72
10. MEDICAL PLAZA PHARMACY -0.36 20. CVS PHARMACY 1.1

Caveats

Given the distorted state of the market, this data does not give a definitive answer as to how much people are paying for their prescription drugs. However, the emergence of prescription price aggregators such as WellRx are making the market more transparent. The transparency they provide creates a quasi-free market among their users as pharmacies compete to appear at the top of the search results.

The data are also influenced by other externalities, such as WellRxโ€™s ability to negotiate in a given market or the introduction of a major competitor such as Walmart, for example. Furthermore, the z-score metric is based on the average price, which fails to take user behavior into account. After all, most consumers shop around, which is why WellRx exists in the first place. That said, using the minimum price as a metric carries its share of caveats as well, as the cheapest option may not be available to all residents of a particular city.

Next Steps

This analysis serves as a starting point for further research on drug pricing. It would be interesting to overlay more data, such as demographic data and cost-of-living indices, to identify further trends. With more granular data, geocoding the data to facilitate analysis of higher-level regional trends as well as neighborhood-level micro-trends to highlight underserved communities.

About Author

Charlie Zien

View all posts by Charlie Zien >

Related Articles

Python
Data Study on the Return to In-Person Dining with OpenTable
Web Scraping
DATA STUDYING THE LABOR MARKET DURING A PANDEMIC
Web Scraping
Scraping Sephora Ingredients: Cruelty Free is Not Enough
Web Scraping
A Comparative Data Analysis on Lab vs. Mined Diamonds
Web Scraping
Scraping podcast data for advertisers

Leave a Comment

Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

No comments found.

View Posts by Categories

All Posts 2399 posts
AI 7 posts
AI Agent 2 posts
AI-based hotel recommendation 1 posts
AIForGood 1 posts
Alumni 60 posts
Animated Maps 1 posts
APIs 41 posts
Artificial Intelligence 2 posts
Artificial Intelligence 2 posts
AWS 13 posts
Banking 1 posts
Big Data 50 posts
Branch Analysis 1 posts
Capstone 206 posts
Career Education 7 posts
CLIP 1 posts
Community 72 posts
Congestion Zone 1 posts
Content Recommendation 1 posts
Cosine SImilarity 1 posts
Data Analysis 5 posts
Data Engineering 1 posts
Data Engineering 3 posts
Data Science 7 posts
Data Science News and Sharing 73 posts
Data Visualization 324 posts
Events 5 posts
Featured 37 posts
Function calling 1 posts
FutureTech 1 posts
Generative AI 5 posts
Hadoop 13 posts
Image Classification 1 posts
Innovation 2 posts
Kmeans Cluster 1 posts
LLM 6 posts
Machine Learning 364 posts
Marketing 1 posts
Meetup 144 posts
MLOPs 1 posts
Model Deployment 1 posts
Nagamas69 1 posts
NLP 1 posts
OpenAI 5 posts
OpenNYC Data 1 posts
pySpark 1 posts
Python 16 posts
Python 458 posts
Python data analysis 4 posts
Python Shiny 2 posts
R 404 posts
R Data Analysis 1 posts
R Shiny 560 posts
R Visualization 445 posts
RAG 1 posts
RoBERTa 1 posts
semantic rearch 2 posts
Spark 17 posts
SQL 1 posts
Streamlit 2 posts
Student Works 1687 posts
Tableau 12 posts
TensorFlow 3 posts
Traffic 1 posts
User Preference Modeling 1 posts
Vector database 2 posts
Web Scraping 483 posts
wukong138 1 posts

Our Recent Popular Posts

AI 4 AI: ChatGPT Unifies My Blog Posts
by Vinod Chugani
Dec 18, 2022
Meet Your Machine Learning Mentors: Kyle Gallatin
by Vivian Zhang
Nov 4, 2020
NICU Admissions and CCHD: Predicting Based on Data Analysis
by Paul Lee, Aron Berke, Bee Kim, Bettina Meier and Ira Villar
Jan 7, 2020

View Posts by Tags

#python #trainwithnycdsa 2019 2020 Revenue 3-points agriculture air quality airbnb airline alcohol Alex Baransky algorithm alumni Alumni Interview Alumni Reviews Alumni Spotlight alumni story Alumnus ames dataset ames housing dataset apartment rent API Application artist aws bank loans beautiful soup Best Bootcamp Best Data Science 2019 Best Data Science Bootcamp Best Data Science Bootcamp 2020 Best Ranked Big Data Book Launch Book-Signing bootcamp Bootcamp Alumni Bootcamp Prep boston safety Bundles cake recipe California Cancer Research capstone car price Career Career Day ChatGPT citibike classic cars classpass clustering Coding Course Demo Course Report covid 19 credit credit card crime frequency crops D3.js data data analysis Data Analyst data analytics data for tripadvisor reviews data science Data Science Academy Data Science Bootcamp Data science jobs Data Science Reviews Data Scientist Data Scientist Jobs data visualization database Deep Learning Demo Day Discount disney dplyr drug data e-commerce economy employee employee burnout employer networking environment feature engineering Finance Financial Data Science fitness studio Flask flight delay football gbm Get Hired ggplot2 googleVis H20 Hadoop hallmark holiday movie happiness healthcare frauds higgs boson Hiring hiring partner events Hiring Partners hotels housing housing data housing predictions housing price hy-vee Income industry Industry Experts Injuries Instructor Blog Instructor Interview insurance italki Job Job Placement Jobs Jon Krohn JP Morgan Chase Kaggle Kickstarter las vegas airport lasso regression Lead Data Scienctist Lead Data Scientist leaflet league linear regression Logistic Regression machine learning Maps market matplotlib Medical Research Meet the team meetup methal health miami beach movie music Napoli NBA netflix Networking neural network Neural networks New Courses NHL nlp NYC NYC Data Science nyc data science academy NYC Open Data nyc property NYCDSA NYCDSA Alumni Online Online Bootcamp Online Training Open Data painter pandas Part-time performance phoenix pollutants Portfolio Development precision measurement prediction Prework Programming public safety PwC python Python Data Analysis python machine learning python scrapy python web scraping python webscraping Python Workshop R R Data Analysis R language R Programming R Shiny r studio R Visualization R Workshop R-bloggers random forest Ranking recommendation recommendation system regression Remote remote data science bootcamp Scrapy scrapy visualization seaborn seafood type Selenium sentiment analysis sentiment classification Shiny Shiny Dashboard Spark Special Special Summer Sports statistics streaming Student Interview Student Showcase SVM Switchup Tableau teachers team team performance TensorFlow Testimonial tf-idf Top Data Science Bootcamp Top manufacturing companies Transfers tweets twitter videos visualization wallstreet wallstreetbets web scraping Weekend Course What to expect whiskey whiskeyadvocate wildfire word cloud word2vec XGBoost yelp youtube trending ZORI

NYC Data Science Academy

NYC Data Science Academy teaches data science, trains companies and their employees to better profit from data, excels at big data project consulting, and connects trained Data Scientists to our industry.

NYC Data Science Academy is licensed by New York State Education Department.

Get detailed curriculum information about our
amazing bootcamp!

Please enter a valid email address
Sign up completed. Thank you!

Offerings

  • HOME
  • DATA SCIENCE BOOTCAMP
  • ONLINE DATA SCIENCE BOOTCAMP
  • Professional Development Courses
  • CORPORATE OFFERINGS
  • HIRING PARTNERS
  • About

  • About Us
  • Alumni
  • Blog
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Refund Policy
  • Join Us
  • SOCIAL MEDIA

    ยฉ 2025 NYC Data Science Academy
    All rights reserved. | Site Map
    Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
    Bootcamp Application