Harmful Chemicals in Cosmetics
The use of cosmetics is growing worldwide. Nowadays, men use cosmetics almost as much as women. Also, cosmetics usage among babies and children has also increased. However, the wide range of products and the complexity of their ingredients raises the concerns of regarding the health effects.. Data visualization based on The California Safe Cosmetics Program can give consumers a quick comparison while making purchasing decision.
The California Safe Cosmetics Program (CSCP) collects data based on The California Safe Cosmetics Act, which requires companies that manufacture cosmetics to report any cosmetics products that contain ingredients known or suspected to cause cancer, birth defects, or other reproductive harm.
Which Category is Being Reported the Most?
Cosmetics covers a wide range of categories. Within the CSCP database, the products are classified into thirteen primary categories, which are Non-Permanent Makeup, Nail, Skin Care, Sun-Related, Bath, Hair Care, Tattoos and Permanent Makeup, Personal Care, Fragrances, Oral Hygiene, Shaving, and Baby.
The first thing for consumers to consider is which category of products they should be more cautious about while making a purchase. This analysis provides an overview of the products reported in each category. Non-permanent Makeup has the highest count compared to other categories, and Baby has the lowest count relatively.
What Kind of Make-up?
After understanding that Non-Permanent Makeup has the highest number of products being reported, the question becomes which of these products is reported the most.
After digging into the sub-category, the analysis shows that Lipsticks/Pencils, Eye Shadow, and Foundations/ Bases are the top three sub-categories.
Chemical Count in Each Category
Sometimes, the products contain more than one kind of chemical. From the violin plot below, we can see that most of the categories contain one kind of chemical, but Non-Permanent Makeup, such as Nail, and Sun-related products, also may contain two kinds of chemicals in a single product. The category one should be most cautious about is Hair Care because some of the products can contain up to nine kinds of chemicals in them.
*Some records contain zero chemical count due to updating report for chemical removal.
In order to have a better understanding while purchasing cosmetics, this analysis gives the top three chemicals that are used the most within each category. With the exception of Personal Care Products, Titanium Dioxide is the chemical that is used the most for every category.
Titanium Dioxide has the stability and ability to protect skin from UV light, and its resistance to discoloration. However, Titanium dioxide dust, when inhaled, has been classified by the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) as an IARC Group 2B carcinogen, meaning it is possibly carcinogenic to humans.
Cocamide Diethanolamine and Retinol / Retinyl Esters are two more chemicals that appear in multiple categories.
Which Company and Brand is Being Reported the Most?
The analysis below indicates that L’Oreal USA and Coty are the top two companies with the highest number of products being reported. The next three are: Procter & Gamble, Bare Escentuals Beauty, Inc., and NYX Los Angeles, Inc.
Looking at the top company, L’Oreal USA, let’s discover which brand under L’Oreal has highest number of products being reported. The word cloud shows that L’Oreal is the top one, and following are Lancome and Maybelline. Then YSL and Giorgio Armani.
Even though it seems like a lot of well-known brands have products containing reportable chemicals, some companies have been taking actions after being reported. From the Timeline of Reported Cosmetics Analysis from 2009 to 2016, it would appear that 2010 was the year with the highest ratio of products first being reported. In the same year, about half of the reported products’ chemicals were removed.
However, in 2011, about 2/3 of the products were reported again. Overall, the number of products reported went down after 2011. Despite a slight increase again in 2014, in general it would appear as if the California law is working to make cosmetics safer. There is a clear trend showing a decrease in reportable chemicals over time.
As for how companies dealt with the challenge of having reportable chemicals in their products, it looks as though there were initial efforts to remove the chemicals, but subsequent to this, products tended to be discontinued rather than altered. This might due to the difficulty of the removal process or the product life-cycle.
- Non-permanent Makeup is most likely to contain reportable chemicals in the product
- Within Non-permanent Makeup, Lipsticks/ Lip Pencils, Eye Shadow, and Foundations/ Bases are the top three categories
- Most categories contain one kind of chemical within the products. Hair Care products are able to contain up to nine kinds of chemicals within the products.
- Titanium Dioxide is the chemical that is used the most in cosmetics
- L’Oreal under L’Oreal USA is the brand that has highest number of products being reported
- Overall trend for the new products being reported is going down. Since 2010 most of the companies choose to discontinue the products rather than remove the chemical.
- Which companies take the longest to remove a chemical or discontinue the products?
- Which company is most likely to be reported a second time?
- Which chemical takes the longest time to remove?
- Which chemical is most likely to be reported second time?