NYC Data Science Academy| Blog
Bootcamps
Lifetime Job Support Available Financing Available
Bootcamps
Data Science with Machine Learning Flagship ๐Ÿ† Data Analytics Bootcamp Artificial Intelligence Bootcamp New Release ๐ŸŽ‰
Free Lesson
Intro to Data Science New Release ๐ŸŽ‰
Find Inspiration
Find Alumni with Similar Background
Job Outlook
Occupational Outlook Graduate Outcomes Must See ๐Ÿ”ฅ
Alumni
Success Stories Testimonials Alumni Directory Alumni Exclusive Study Program
Courses
View Bundled Courses
Financing Available
Bootcamp Prep Popular ๐Ÿ”ฅ Data Science Mastery Data Science Launchpad with Python View AI Courses Generative AI for Everyone New ๐ŸŽ‰ Generative AI for Finance New ๐ŸŽ‰ Generative AI for Marketing New ๐ŸŽ‰
Bundle Up
Learn More and Save More
Combination of data science courses.
View Data Science Courses
Beginner
Introductory Python
Intermediate
Data Science Python: Data Analysis and Visualization Popular ๐Ÿ”ฅ Data Science R: Data Analysis and Visualization
Advanced
Data Science Python: Machine Learning Popular ๐Ÿ”ฅ Data Science R: Machine Learning Designing and Implementing Production MLOps New ๐ŸŽ‰ Natural Language Processing for Production (NLP) New ๐ŸŽ‰
Find Inspiration
Get Course Recommendation Must Try ๐Ÿ’Ž An Ultimate Guide to Become a Data Scientist
For Companies
For Companies
Corporate Offerings Hiring Partners Candidate Portfolio Hire Our Graduates
Students Work
Students Work
All Posts Capstone Data Visualization Machine Learning Python Projects R Projects
Tutorials
About
About
About Us Accreditation Contact Us Join Us FAQ Webinars Subscription An Ultimate Guide to
Become a Data Scientist
    Login
NYC Data Science Acedemy
Bootcamps
Courses
Students Work
About
Bootcamps
Bootcamps
Data Science with Machine Learning Flagship
Data Analytics Bootcamp
Artificial Intelligence Bootcamp New Release ๐ŸŽ‰
Free Lessons
Intro to Data Science New Release ๐ŸŽ‰
Find Inspiration
Find Alumni with Similar Background
Job Outlook
Occupational Outlook
Graduate Outcomes Must See ๐Ÿ”ฅ
Alumni
Success Stories
Testimonials
Alumni Directory
Alumni Exclusive Study Program
Courses
Bundles
financing available
View All Bundles
Bootcamp Prep
Data Science Mastery
Data Science Launchpad with Python NEW!
View AI Courses
Generative AI for Everyone
Generative AI for Finance
Generative AI for Marketing
View Data Science Courses
View All Professional Development Courses
Beginner
Introductory Python
Intermediate
Python: Data Analysis and Visualization
R: Data Analysis and Visualization
Advanced
Python: Machine Learning
R: Machine Learning
Designing and Implementing Production MLOps
Natural Language Processing for Production (NLP)
For Companies
Corporate Offerings
Hiring Partners
Candidate Portfolio
Hire Our Graduates
Students Work
All Posts
Capstone
Data Visualization
Machine Learning
Python Projects
R Projects
About
Accreditation
About Us
Contact Us
Join Us
FAQ
Webinars
Subscription
An Ultimate Guide to Become a Data Scientist
Tutorials
Data Analytics
  • Learn Pandas
  • Learn NumPy
  • Learn SciPy
  • Learn Matplotlib
Machine Learning
  • Boosting
  • Random Forest
  • Linear Regression
  • Decision Tree
  • PCA
Interview by Companies
  • JPMC
  • Google
  • Facebook
Artificial Intelligence
  • Learn Generative AI
  • Learn ChatGPT-3.5
  • Learn ChatGPT-4
  • Learn Google Bard
Coding
  • Learn Python
  • Learn SQL
  • Learn MySQL
  • Learn NoSQL
  • Learn PySpark
  • Learn PyTorch
Interview Questions
  • Python Hard
  • R Easy
  • R Hard
  • SQL Easy
  • SQL Hard
  • Python Easy
Data Science Blog > Data Visualization > Using Data to Analyze: How Caring is Home Health Care?

Using Data to Analyze: How Caring is Home Health Care?

Daniel Nie
Posted on Nov 4, 2021
An exploration of Home Health Agency data to determine factors associated with patient health outcomes

Shiny App

GitHub

LinkedIn

Motivation

Home Healthcare provides medical care to patients in the comfort of their own homes. It is typically used for transitional care, allowing patients to return home early after invasive surgery.  But it also plays a role in delivering preventive care to the elderly and frail and has been shown to be effective in reducing mortality and admission to long-term care institutions for the elderly.

Home healthcare spending has grown rapidly. According to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), expenditures on home health increased 7.7% in 2019, outpacing the total healthcare spending increase of 4.6% for the same period. However, as evident in the CMS Quality indicators , there are large discrepancies in the quality of care provided by different agencies.ong-term care for the elderly and frail.

My project begins by exploring the geographic and cost variations among home health agencies before digging deeper to determine factors associated with their patient health outcomes. Full results, interactive maps and charts can be found on the project Shiny App.

Data and Methods

The CMS provides data on its 11,000 Medicare-certified agencies across the country. It includes information on the type of ownership, star-rating, and other quality measures. I combined that with a separate dataset on agency patient experience surveys.

In order to conduct geographic utilization analysis, census data provided me with age-segmented state populations, as well as disability prevalence rates.

Exploratory descriptive analysis was used to examine current geographic utilization rates, costs and agency star-ratings. Kruskal-Wallis ANOVA and the Bartlett test were used to discern significant differences among the types of agencies (privately owned, government owned, or non-profit). Finally, linear regression was used to determine factors associated with patient outcomes, namely acute care admissions rate and discharge to community (DTC) rate.

Geographic Variations in Utilization & Cost

In the 1990s when Home Health Services just started to become more popular, there was dramatic geographic variation in its utilization. The southeast region (TN, MS, LA, AL, GA) had the highest concentrations of home visits. Today, the situation hasnโ€™t changed much. The highest use of Home Health still occurs in the southeast (figures 1 & 2). Some northeast states like Massachusetts, Vermont, and New Hampshire have increased utilization, perhaps due to dense senior populations in those states.

Figures 1 & 2: Number of cases per 100,000 Seniors by State

Figure 3 below maps differences in average state costs (as a ratio to the national average). As you can see, state averages range from 0.87 to 1.07, while individual agency costs can range from 0.5 to even 2x the national average. Additional interactive density maps are on the projectโ€™s Shiny App.

Figure 3: Agency Costs as a Ratio vs. National Average

These cost differences may be due to the competitive environment in the agencyโ€™s home state, and past studies have also shown regulations called certificate of need (CON) laws greatly affect agency costs. In a later part of the analysis, I examine if patient outcomes were associated with cost discrepancies.

Star Rating

The CMS uses a curved rating system; only top performers in its 9 measurements of quality can receive high ratings. Only 15% of agencies nationwide received 4.5 or 5 stars (figure 4).

For agencies with a 3-star rating or better, the Discharge to Community rates are equal (~80%). However, outcomes start to worsen for poorly rated agencies. We also observe a slight drop in Patient Experience survey results for poorly rated agencies (figures 5 & 6).

Figures 4, 5 & 6: Star Rating Distribution, Discharge to Community Rates, & Patient Experience on Communication

Interestingly, there was a bimodal distribution in the type of agency in relation to star-rating (figure 7). Agencies with both high and low star ratings are mostly privately owned, while those with medium ratings are not. The next sections involve statistical analysis and we begin with determining how costs and patient outcomes differed between types of agencies.

Figure 7: Percentage of Privately Owned Agency by Star Rating

Type of Agency Ownership

The variance of costs differed significantly between types of ownership. Private and government owned agency costs varied greatly, while non-profit agency costs ranged closer to 1.0. The Kruskal-Wallis test showed means were significantly different, and we can observe from the ridge-line chart on the right that private agencies had higher mean costs (figure 8).

The mean discharge to community rates differed significantly among the different types of agency ownership. Non-profit agencies typically performed better. Mean acute care admissions rates between agency types were also significantly different, with private agencies performing better (figures 9 & 10). 

Figures 8, 9 & 10: Agency Ownership Charts

 

Patient Outcome Measures

Linear regression was used in an attempt to determine factors associated with home health agency patient outcomes, specifically acute care admissions rates and discharge to community rates.

Using nation-wide data points resulted in extremely low R-squares. Perhaps the regulatory environment or market conditions are too different between states to conduct any inter-state comparisons. Instead, I ran separate regressions for data from two individual states. I chose Texas as it had the most agencies (1400+), and Florida, the state with the 3rd most agencies (~800), and known for its high senior population density. Here I will summarize results from Florida, for full results, please refer to the Shiny App.

Notes: Step-wise feature selection (Forward BIC) was used to find appropriate independent variables for each model. When star-rating was included as an independent variable, other features that went into star-rating calculation were excluded and vice versa.

Acute Care Admissions

With acute care admissions as the target dependent variable, forward BIC selected Cost and Communication (% patients that reported their health team communicated well with them) as features. The ฮฒ coefficient for Communication was -0.055 (p<0.01). That means for each 1 percent improvement in that factor, admission rate was reduced by 0.05 percent. The relationship is not large, which explains the low R2 of 0.122 (although it was still an improvement from the nation-wide regression).

The ฮฒ coefficient of Cost was 10.15, which is not ideal for patients.  A 1 unit increase in cost, meaning starting from 1 and going to 2 - double the national average - actually increased admissions rates. Prediction bands are shown in figure 11 below.

This result actually points to a major limitation to my analysis and deficiencies of the data set. The positive relationship between an increase in costs and increase in admissions risk may be due to a home health agencyโ€™s patient case-mix. Patients with complex disease and higher risk are charged more for services. If agency data included information on patient disease, it would be better to conduct separate analysis for each patient risk level.

Figure 11: Acute care admission regressed on Cost, with prediction lines

Discharge to Community Rate

As for discharge to community (DTC) rate, forward BIC selected Cost and Bed (how often patients got better getting in & out of bed independently). The ฮฒ coefficient for Bed was 0.24 (p<0.01) which meant a positive association between improving patient bed mobility and improved agency DTC rate. The ฮฒ for Cost (-28.8) was again pointing to a lack of data on patient risk profile, as increasing agency costs worsened the expected DTC rate. This could also mean agencies were used by some patients as a replacement for institutionalised long-term care, thus delaying discharge back to the community.

Conclusions

Our within-state regression analysis showed some association between patient experiences regarding caregiver communication and acute care admissions. Home healthcare teams should emphasize better communication with patients and households. Healthcare teams could also focus on improving patients' ability to get in and out of bed as this factor was correlated with better discharge to community rates.

The within-state analysis showed that more expensive agencies correlated with higher acute care admissions and lower DTC rates. This means at-risk patients with complicated illnesses pay more and may even be using home health as an alternative to institutional long-term care. This could be a desirable alternative.

Recommendations to Home Healthcare Patients

Agency Star Ratings are given by the CMS and not by patients. It correlates well with quality of care. Patients are advised to hire an agency with at least 3 stars

Patients and family members should make sure agency caregivers spend time communicating with them about their illness, pain, and medication. If the patient or caregiver feels dissatisfied, they should  ask the agency or doctor to request a replacement for the home health team.

Limitations & Further Analysis

Regression analysis did not yield strong results. This could be due to missing detailed agency data, such as: (1) the exact number of home health staff or teams, (2) team composition, e.g. skilled nurses, home aides, etc., and most importantly, (3) agency patient case-mix or risk profiles.

As next steps to the study, if agency patient information is available, studying agency features against patient outcomes for specific diseases, like diabetes mellitus, COPD, or cancer, could yield valuable results.

The skills I demoed here can be learned through taking Data Science with Machine Learning bootcamp with NYC Data Science Academy.

About Author

Daniel Nie

Data Scientist with background experience in both Healthcare Administration and Finance. A versatile thinker that enjoys deep data exploration and generating business value with machine learning in both Python and R
View all posts by Daniel Nie >

Related Articles

Capstone
Catching Fraud in the Healthcare System
Data Analysis
Car Sales Report R Shiny App
Data Analysis
Injury Analysis of Soccer Players with Python
Capstone
Acquisition Due Dilligence Automation for Smaller Firms
R Shiny
Forecasting NY State Tax Credits: R Shiny App for Businesses

Leave a Comment

No comments found.

View Posts by Categories

All Posts 2399 posts
AI 7 posts
AI Agent 2 posts
AI-based hotel recommendation 1 posts
AIForGood 1 posts
Alumni 60 posts
Animated Maps 1 posts
APIs 41 posts
Artificial Intelligence 2 posts
Artificial Intelligence 2 posts
AWS 13 posts
Banking 1 posts
Big Data 50 posts
Branch Analysis 1 posts
Capstone 206 posts
Career Education 7 posts
CLIP 1 posts
Community 72 posts
Congestion Zone 1 posts
Content Recommendation 1 posts
Cosine SImilarity 1 posts
Data Analysis 5 posts
Data Engineering 1 posts
Data Engineering 3 posts
Data Science 7 posts
Data Science News and Sharing 73 posts
Data Visualization 324 posts
Events 5 posts
Featured 37 posts
Function calling 1 posts
FutureTech 1 posts
Generative AI 5 posts
Hadoop 13 posts
Image Classification 1 posts
Innovation 2 posts
Kmeans Cluster 1 posts
LLM 6 posts
Machine Learning 364 posts
Marketing 1 posts
Meetup 144 posts
MLOPs 1 posts
Model Deployment 1 posts
Nagamas69 1 posts
NLP 1 posts
OpenAI 5 posts
OpenNYC Data 1 posts
pySpark 1 posts
Python 16 posts
Python 458 posts
Python data analysis 4 posts
Python Shiny 2 posts
R 404 posts
R Data Analysis 1 posts
R Shiny 560 posts
R Visualization 445 posts
RAG 1 posts
RoBERTa 1 posts
semantic rearch 2 posts
Spark 17 posts
SQL 1 posts
Streamlit 2 posts
Student Works 1687 posts
Tableau 12 posts
TensorFlow 3 posts
Traffic 1 posts
User Preference Modeling 1 posts
Vector database 2 posts
Web Scraping 483 posts
wukong138 1 posts

Our Recent Popular Posts

AI 4 AI: ChatGPT Unifies My Blog Posts
by Vinod Chugani
Dec 18, 2022
Meet Your Machine Learning Mentors: Kyle Gallatin
by Vivian Zhang
Nov 4, 2020
NICU Admissions and CCHD: Predicting Based on Data Analysis
by Paul Lee, Aron Berke, Bee Kim, Bettina Meier and Ira Villar
Jan 7, 2020

View Posts by Tags

#python #trainwithnycdsa 2019 2020 Revenue 3-points agriculture air quality airbnb airline alcohol Alex Baransky algorithm alumni Alumni Interview Alumni Reviews Alumni Spotlight alumni story Alumnus ames dataset ames housing dataset apartment rent API Application artist aws bank loans beautiful soup Best Bootcamp Best Data Science 2019 Best Data Science Bootcamp Best Data Science Bootcamp 2020 Best Ranked Big Data Book Launch Book-Signing bootcamp Bootcamp Alumni Bootcamp Prep boston safety Bundles cake recipe California Cancer Research capstone car price Career Career Day ChatGPT citibike classic cars classpass clustering Coding Course Demo Course Report covid 19 credit credit card crime frequency crops D3.js data data analysis Data Analyst data analytics data for tripadvisor reviews data science Data Science Academy Data Science Bootcamp Data science jobs Data Science Reviews Data Scientist Data Scientist Jobs data visualization database Deep Learning Demo Day Discount disney dplyr drug data e-commerce economy employee employee burnout employer networking environment feature engineering Finance Financial Data Science fitness studio Flask flight delay football gbm Get Hired ggplot2 googleVis H20 Hadoop hallmark holiday movie happiness healthcare frauds higgs boson Hiring hiring partner events Hiring Partners hotels housing housing data housing predictions housing price hy-vee Income industry Industry Experts Injuries Instructor Blog Instructor Interview insurance italki Job Job Placement Jobs Jon Krohn JP Morgan Chase Kaggle Kickstarter las vegas airport lasso regression Lead Data Scienctist Lead Data Scientist leaflet league linear regression Logistic Regression machine learning Maps market matplotlib Medical Research Meet the team meetup methal health miami beach movie music Napoli NBA netflix Networking neural network Neural networks New Courses NHL nlp NYC NYC Data Science nyc data science academy NYC Open Data nyc property NYCDSA NYCDSA Alumni Online Online Bootcamp Online Training Open Data painter pandas Part-time performance phoenix pollutants Portfolio Development precision measurement prediction Prework Programming public safety PwC python Python Data Analysis python machine learning python scrapy python web scraping python webscraping Python Workshop R R Data Analysis R language R Programming R Shiny r studio R Visualization R Workshop R-bloggers random forest Ranking recommendation recommendation system regression Remote remote data science bootcamp Scrapy scrapy visualization seaborn seafood type Selenium sentiment analysis sentiment classification Shiny Shiny Dashboard Spark Special Special Summer Sports statistics streaming Student Interview Student Showcase SVM Switchup Tableau teachers team team performance TensorFlow Testimonial tf-idf Top Data Science Bootcamp Top manufacturing companies Transfers tweets twitter videos visualization wallstreet wallstreetbets web scraping Weekend Course What to expect whiskey whiskeyadvocate wildfire word cloud word2vec XGBoost yelp youtube trending ZORI

NYC Data Science Academy

NYC Data Science Academy teaches data science, trains companies and their employees to better profit from data, excels at big data project consulting, and connects trained Data Scientists to our industry.

NYC Data Science Academy is licensed by New York State Education Department.

Get detailed curriculum information about our
amazing bootcamp!

Please enter a valid email address
Sign up completed. Thank you!

Offerings

  • HOME
  • DATA SCIENCE BOOTCAMP
  • ONLINE DATA SCIENCE BOOTCAMP
  • Professional Development Courses
  • CORPORATE OFFERINGS
  • HIRING PARTNERS
  • About

  • About Us
  • Alumni
  • Blog
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Refund Policy
  • Join Us
  • SOCIAL MEDIA

    ยฉ 2025 NYC Data Science Academy
    All rights reserved. | Site Map
    Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
    Bootcamp Application